An effective fraud response is only the beginning to combatting fraud: the real challenge comes after the immediate threat has been contained. Recovery requires more than restoring systems or reconciling losses; it’s about rebuilding trust, strengthening internal controls and learning from what happened to prevent it from happening again. For small and mid-sized businesses (SMBs), that means approaching recovery as both a practical and strategic process. One that balances transparency, accountability and long-term resilience.

In this next installment of our series, Steve Lenderman, isolved’s Head of Fraud Prevention, shares insights into how SMBs can recover from a fraud incident with confidence. From assessing the full scope of impact and managing stakeholder communication to implementing corrective measures and refining policies, this discussion explores how organizations can turn a setback into an opportunity to build a stronger, more fraud-resistant foundation for the future.

Q.      Are there specific insurance policies that can help businesses recover from fraud losses?

Yes, businesses can recover from fraud losses through specific insurance policies like commercial crime insurance, fidelity bonds and business fraud insurance. Commercial crime and fidelity bonds typically cover employee theft and forgery. Cyber fraud coverage often requires a separate cyber liability policy or endorsement. Cyber insurance providers may assist in preserving coverage and recovery resources.

Q.      How can SMBs reassure stakeholders, like customers, investors or partners, after an incident?

In the aftermath of a fraud incident, controlling the narrative starts with honesty and clarity. Communicate verified facts, acknowledge the impact and explain what’s known. For example, “We identified a fraud incident affecting [X]. We’ve contained the issue and are working with experts to resolve it.” Reassure stakeholders that the threat has been neutralized by outlining concrete actions, such as system lockdowns, password resets and forensic reviews.

Maintain open communication through regular updates, FAQs or dedicated contact channels, and close with a reaffirmation of your organization’s values and commitment to security and trust. Finally, emphasize your recovery plan, including audits, training, policy improvements and technology upgrades, to demonstrate accountability and forward progress.

Q.      How can SMBs track whether their new prevention measures are working?

To measure the effectiveness of prevention methods, SMBs need to define key performance indicators (KPIs). Some KPIs that will likely prove useful for measuring the effectiveness of prevention include:

• Incident Frequency: Are fraud attempts decreasing over time?
• Detection Speed: How quickly are threats identified and escalated?
• Employee Reporting Rates: Are more employees flagging suspicious activity?
• False Positive Rates: Are alerts accurate and actionable?

To test and measure the KPIs, conduct regular internal audits of access logs, transaction records and approval workflows to identify any anomalies, policy violations or signs of circumvention. Run simulated attacks, such as phishing, social engineering or red team exercises to observe how employees respond and whether systems flag the activity.  Use system logs or spot checks to verify and track employee adherence to updated protocols, like dual approvals and verification steps, and policies.

KPIs can then be used to continually update and refine your fraud strategy to ensure progress doesn’t stop after the initial rollout. Review external reports and alerts from banks, vendors or cybersecurity partners and compare incident trends with industry benchmarks or peer organizations. Gather employee feedback on whether the training improved their confidence and awareness. Use surveys or informal check-ins to identify lingering confusion or gaps.

From there, you can apply your findings to refine controls, training and response plans. Continue to treat fraud prevention like maintaining a strong defense line: it needs consistent practice, review and reinforcement to stay effective.

Q.      What are some simple, practical ways to build fraud awareness into everyday business culture?

Resilience in Reporting

• Simplify Reporting: Make it easy to report concerns via anonymous forms, dedicated email or a chatbot. Ensure employees know how and where to report without fear of backlash.
• Celebrate Smart Reporting: Recognize employees who flag suspicious activity even if it turns out to be benign. Foster a culture of curiosity and caution rather than paranoia.

Fine-Tuning Training and Awareness

• Share Real Stories: Use anonymized case studies from your industry or internal incidents to show how fraud happens. Highlight what was learned and how it was prevented next time.
• Post Visual Reminders: Use posters, digital signage or desktop wallpaper with fraud red flags and reporting steps. Keep it fresh with rotating monthly themes.
• Use Micro-Training Moments: Share short fraud tips in team meetings, newsletters or team channels.

Creating a Collaborative Company Culture

• Make Fraud Part of Onboarding: Include fraud scenarios and reporting protocols in new hire orientation. Reinforce that fraud prevention is everyone’s responsibility, not just IT or finance.
• Embed in Routine Processes: Add fraud checkpoints to workflows: dual approvals, verification steps or “pause and confirm” prompts. For example, before processing a wire transfer, require a secondary confirmation from a different channel.
• Gamify Awareness: Run phishing simulations or fraud quizzes with small incentives. Create team challenges around spotting red flags in mock scenarios.

Recovering from fraud extends beyond repairing systems and recovering funds. It’s about restoring confidence, both inside and outside the organization. For SMBs, the recovery phase is an opportunity to turn disruption into progress by identifying what went wrong, reinforcing controls, and strengthening trust with employees, customers and partners.

True resilience comes from learning and adapting, not just responding in real time. With clear priorities, transparent communication and a commitment to continuous improvement, businesses can emerge from a fraud incident more resilient, wiser and confidently positioned for the future.

To stay in the know about the latest fraud, cyber and security trends, register for the upcoming webinar on December 9— "Inside the Next Wave of Cybercrime: 2026’s Biggest Scams and How to Outsmart Them.”

_{Disclaimer. The information provided herein is for general informational purposes only and is not intended to be legal, investment or tax advice. It is not a substitute for professional legal, investment or tax advice, and you should not rely on it as such. No attorney-client or accountant-client relationship or any other kind of relationship is formed by any use of this information. The effective date of various provisions, amendments, and regulatory guidance may impact eligibility. The accuracy, completeness, correctness or adequacy of the information is not guaranteed, and isolved assumes no responsibility or liability for any errors or omissions in the content. You should consult with an attorney, investment professional or tax professional for advice regarding your specific situation.} 

Print